Eldersburg or Catonsville?
Both unincorporated, both built around a state road, in different counties.
The short version
Neither pays a town tax. Carroll County’s total rate is lower than Baltimore County’s, and Carroll has no county transfer tax where Baltimore County charges 1.5%. Catonsville is at the Beltway, next to Baltimore City, with a village center on Frederick Road and housing that is mostly older. Eldersburg is farther out, mostly subdivisions and townhome communities, with Liberty Reservoir along its eastern edge.
On a $400,000 assessment, the yearly property tax is about $328 lower in Eldersburg at the rates below.
Side by side
| What is compared | Eldersburg | Catonsville |
|---|---|---|
| County | Carroll County | Baltimore County |
| Local government | Unincorporated. Carroll County is the local government. | Unincorporated. Baltimore County is the local government. |
| Property tax rate, per $100 of assessed value | $1.130Carroll County $1.018 + State of Maryland $0.112. | $1.212Baltimore County $1.100 + State of Maryland $0.112. |
| Yearly tax on a $400,000 assessment | $4,520At the rate above. | $4,848At the rate above. |
| Also on the tax bill | Nothing extra to note. | Homes on public water and sewer also see water and sewer charges on the tax bill. The county calls them Metropolitan District charges. |
| County transfer tax at settlement | None. Carroll County has no county transfer tax. | 1.5% of the price, county transfer tax. |
| Homestead credit: yearly cap on assessment increases for owner-occupants | 5% a year on the county portion | 4% a year on the county portion |
| Housing you’ll find | Mostly subdivisions of single-family homes, along with townhome communities and some newer construction. | Victorian and early twentieth-century houses, brick colonials and Cape Cods, mid-century ranchers and split-levels, plus some townhomes and condominiums. |
| Main roads | MD 26 runs east toward Baltimore County and I-695. MD 32 runs south to Sykesville and I-70. | I-695 passes through the east side, with US 40, Frederick Road and I-95 close by. |
| Commuter rail | No commuter rail station in Carroll County. | Halethorpe station on the MARC Penn Line is nearby in Baltimore County. |
| Worth knowing | Eldersburg is unincorporated, so there is no town tax. County and state property taxes apply. | Baltimore County has no incorporated towns, so there is one county tax rate plus the state’s. |
Rates are for the tax year July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027, checked November 19, 2026. Sources: Maryland Department of Assessments and Taxation, 2026-2027 county and municipal tax rates; Howard County Department of Finance, real property tax rate schedule effective July 1, 2026, and county transfer tax; Baltimore County, deed transfer and recordation. Property tax is charged on the assessed value, which isn’t the same as the price you pay. Every county also charges a recordation tax at settlement, and Maryland charges a state transfer tax of 0.5%. Confirm the figures for a specific address with your title company and the state’s assessment record for that parcel.
What homes are selling for in Eldersburg and Catonsville
Sale prices move month to month, so they aren’t printed here. Tell me the kind of home you’re after and I’ll send you what has sold in both towns in the last few months.
Keep comparing
- Eldersburg community guide
- Catonsville community guide
- Sykesville vs. Eldersburg
- Sykesville vs. Catonsville
- Eldersburg vs. Westminster
- Eldersburg vs. Ellicott City
- Westminster vs. Catonsville
- Ellicott City vs. Catonsville
- Monthly cost of a specific house, on Baltimore Numbers
- Where to find school and safety information
Still deciding
Weighing Eldersburg against Catonsville?
I work in both. Tell me what matters to you in a house and I’ll tell you how I’d look at these two. There’s no cost and no obligation.